DIY vs. Pre-Assembled: Which Window Screen Option is Right for You?
When it comes time to refresh your home’s screens, you generally find yourself at a crossroads: Do you spend a Saturday morning building them yourself from a kit, or do you order them fully assembled and ready to "pop" into the frame?
At Shade Screen Solutions, we offer both. But the right choice depends on your budget, your tools, and—most importantly—your patience. Here is a breakdown of the DIY vs. Pre-Assembled debate to help you decide.
The Case for DIY: Custom Window Screen Kits
If you’re a weekend warrior who enjoys the satisfaction of a job well done, a DIY Window Screen Kit is often the most cost-effective path.
The Benefits:
-
Significant Savings on Shipping: This is the "secret" advantage. Fully assembled screens are like shipping giant picture frames; they require large boxes and specialized handling. Kits ship in compact, standard-sized boxes, often saving you $50–$100 on shipping alone for larger orders.
-
Immediate Availability: While custom-assembled screens take time to build in our shop, kits often ship faster because the "assembly" labor is on your schedule.
-
Customization on the Fly: If you have an odd-sized window, a kit allows you to make micro-adjustments during the build process.
The Trade-Off:
Building a screen from scratch requires a Mitre Saw (to cut the aluminum frames) and a steady hand with a spline roller. If you’ve never "splined" a screen before, there is a learning curve to avoid "bowing" the frame.
The Case for Pre-Assembled: Ready-to-Install
For many homeowners, the value of their time far outweighs the cost of assembly. Fully Assembled Screens arrive at your door built to the 1/16th of an inch, using professional-grade tensioning machines.
The Benefits:
-
No Tools Required: You don’t need a saw, a roller, or a workspace. You simply unbox the screens and place them in the window.
-
Professional Tension: One of the hardest parts of DIY is getting the mesh tight without warping the frame. Our assembled screens are guaranteed to be flat, tight, and square.
-
Access to Premium Hardware: Our factory-assembled screens can include specialized hardware like plunger bolts or tension springs that are difficult to install correctly in a DIY setting.
The Trade-Off:
The primary downside is the Shipping Cost. Because assembled screens are fragile and oversized, they require heavy-duty cardboard and custom wood framing to ensure they arrive without being bent by the courier.
The "Hybrid" Solution: Pre-Cut DIY Kits
Don't want to use a power saw, but want to save on shipping? We offer Custom Screen Kits where we cut the frames to your exact measurements, but let you handle the mesh and spline assembly. It’s the perfect middle ground: No power tools needed, and low shipping costs.
Comparison Table: At a Glance
| Feature | DIY Kits (Uncut) | Pre-Cut Kits | Fully Assembled |
| Cost | Lowest | Moderate | Highest |
| Shipping Price | $ | $ | $$$ |
| Tools Needed | Saw, Spline Roller | Spline Roller only | None |
| Skill Level | Intermediate | Beginner | None |
| Best For | Budget Projects | Precise DIYers | Maximum Quality & Ease |
Summary: Which Should You Buy?
-
Choose a Kit if you are replacing multiple screens on a budget and feel comfortable working with your hands.
-
Choose Pre-Assembled if you are upgrading to high-performance mesh (like SunTex 90 or AllergyGuard) and want to ensure the installation looks flawless and professional.
Not sure which route to take? Browse our Assembled Window Screens and compare them to our DIY Frame Kits to see the price difference for your specific sizes.
